Between wrangling kids, prepping side dishes, and trying to keep the kitchen from turning into chaos, Thanksgiving can feel… well, a little less than picture-perfect. And that’s okay. There’s absolutely no shame in outsourcing part of your meal — especially dessert!
Whether you’ve got a baby on your hip, a toddler “helping” with the flour, or just need a breather this holiday season, these local bakeries and markets around the Sebago Lake region are ready to help. Pre-order your pies, pick them up fresh, and savor the homemade flavor (without the mess).
💌 Don’t Miss a Week of Local Family Fun
Get the best Sebago Lake Region events, holiday guides, and local food finds — delivered straight to your inbox every Thursday morning!
Local Pie Pre-Orders
Poland Provisions (Poland)
Order online by November 23.
Their pies are made from scratch and can be conveniently ordered through ToastTab for easy pickup.
👉 Order here
Sullivan House Bakery (Gorham)
Pre-order by Saturday, November 15.
This small-town bakery is beloved for its flaky crusts and seasonal flavors.
👉 View details
Zilli’s Small Batch Bakery (Windham)
Thanksgiving pre-orders are closed, but don’t worry—Christmas cookie orders are already open!
👉 Order holiday cookies
Hailey’s Kitchen (Windham)
Offering homemade pies and desserts made with love right in the Lakes Region.
👉 See options
The Good Life Market (Raymond)
Pre-order by November 22.
Their annual Thanksgiving menu includes classic pies and local specialties.
👉 View menu (PDF)
Black Bear Bakery 207 (Buxton)
Pre-order by November 22.
From traditional pumpkin to decadent chocolate cream, their pies are always crowd-pleasers.
👉 See their Instagram post
Sweet and Savory Bakery (Standish)
Pre-order by November 21.
A local favorite for rich fillings and perfect crusts.
👉 Order here
Orchard Ridge Farm (Gorham)
Handmade pies featuring fresh, local ingredients — perfect for a true farm-to-table Thanksgiving.
👉 View details
Miller’s Market (Gorham)
Pre-order by November 21.
A local go-to for delicious homemade desserts and holiday staples.
👉 Order here
Waxwing Bakery (Windham)
Pre-order by November 16.
Their rustic pies and breads are worth the drive.
👉 Visit website
The Kitchen (Limington)
Homemade pies and other Thanksgiving favorites available for pre-order.
👉 See their Facebook post
Kindred Farms (Casco)
Pre-order by November 21.
Offering local, handmade pies perfect for your holiday table.
👉 Order here
Pineland Farms (New Gloucester)
Pre-order by November 20.
Choose from a wide selection of bakery items and holiday sides.
👉 View menu
🍂 Keep Thanksgiving Simple (and Sweet)
Homemade or store-bought, what really matters is time together — not who rolled out the crust. Outsourcing dessert (or any part of your meal!) can give you more time to relax, visit, and enjoy the holiday with your family.
If you’ve got little ones underfoot, this is your sign to skip the stress, pre-order a pie (or two), and spend that extra time making memories — not doing dishes. 🧡
💌 Want more local food finds, family events, and holiday fun?
Subscribe to the free Lake Region Kids Calendar newsletter for weekly updates — delivered every Thursday morning!
Leave a Reply